The big corporations are not the only one spinning backflips. Easily half of the renewable developers that I am connected to on LinkedIn are now working in data center development. The day to day work is virtually the same. The motivation is turned on its head. Fear (of not being able to get a job in renewables) and greed (the dollars are much, much bigger now) are the drivers.
Great piece (per usual). I have reservations, though, about continuing to use the word “greed” to explain these guys’ behavior. I think they’re now operating in a psycho-emotional realm far beyond greed. It’s more like an Olympian-level rutting extravaganza among a small group of situational narcissists in their quest for godlike status via the public crushing of male competitors. Essentially a giant game of “king of the mountain” whose real stakes - to which these warring gods are blind - is the suffering of the spectators.
I understand winning involves making the most money, and I understand greed can mean thirst for power as well as dollars, but I still think it’s an inadequate term for the impulse behind these men’s boundless level of ego-based, competitive amorality.
It woud be nice if companies would inrnalities the externalities that they cause, but its the job of policymakers to create the incentives for companies to do so (and the climate movement to create the incentives for politicians to do so)
The $10,000 checks aren't just corporate greed, they are the down payment on a massive state-backed bailout.
Bill, calling out Big Tech’s hypocrisy and community buyouts hits the mark on their PR rot, but treating this as merely "billionaire lying" misses the real game theory at play. Big AI Tech is staring down an astronomical CapEx bubble, billions sunk into GPUs and data center real estate with unviable unit returns. They aren't just bribing towns to build; they are executing a "Moral Hazard by Design" strategy.
By paying off local communities to force through zoning changes today, tech giants trick regional utilities and municipalities into incurring massive public debt to upgrade the grid. When the speculative AI bubble inevitably bursts, Big Tech won't take the hit, they'll default on or renegotiate their long-term Power Purchase Agreements under the guise of "market adjustments" or "climate-mandated pauses." Ratepayers and taxpayers will be left holding the bill for stranded fossil and grid infrastructure, socializing the losses while Big Tech walks away with privatized IP and state-sanctioned regulatory moats that lock out any remaining competition.
As one commenter Wayne Teel correctly noted above, energy consumption itself is the systemic engine, and as Brian’s poll data starkly shows, the general public ranks "climate" dead last when economic pressures hit. Swapping compute energy for a hyper-electrified "green" grid changes nothing. Wind, solar, and grid-scale batteries are rebuildable energy converters, industrial products reliant on destructive open-pit mining, toxic refining, and fossil fuels. You cannot engineer an inherently unsustainable, growth-dependent machine into sustainability. Industrial civilisation will not voluntarily shrink its throughput; it will run until nature’s limits force a catastrophic thermodynamic reset.
Seren, comparing the current AI bubble to 1929 misses a fundamental difference in physical reality. The crash of 1929 was a paper financial panic occurring within a young, expanding industrial system that still had vast, unexploited reserves of high-EROEI oil, pristine topsoil, and massive ecological slack to rebuild upon. When that bubble burst, the physical resource base remained entirely intact, allowing credit and industrial capital to eventually re-expand and drive another multi-decade growth cycle.
A modern 2020s or 2030s crash will hit a society that is simultaneously suffering from energy limits, declining resource quality, and severe ecological overshoot. We are burning through finite, lower-grade fossil fuels just to build out "REbuildable" energy converters and data center grids that yield no real net-energy return. When this CapEx bubble bursts, it won't just wipe out paper wealth; it will paralyse physical supply chains and leave communities saddled with stranded grid liabilities at the exact moment nature's limits prevent us from ever rebuilding the high-energy machine. It won't be a temporary financial depression followed by a new boom, but a permanent step down the staircase of industrial decline.
The gap between the pledge and the number is the part that gets me every time — emissions up double digits at multiple companies that made public net-zero commitments years ago. A pledge that isn't holding under its own growth targets isn't really a pledge anymore, it's a press release with an expiration date nobody announced.
I cannot wrap my head around the 'need' for expanding data centers to seemingly every corner of the world. What for? tRump and the META-verse team already live inside our heads and largely control our behaviors. And now perhaps the coup-de-grace, populous level bribery?
The plutocrats are swimming in dollars with nowhere to put them except projects that extirpate human individual sovereignty.
We’re talking about AI as if the transition to a cleaner energy system can happen underneath it automatically, while some of the fastest-growing AI infrastructure is creating new demand for gas and other fossil generation.
The question I keep asking is: what happens when AI demand grows faster than clean power and grid infrastructure can be built?
That timing gap may end up being one of the most important climate stories of the AI boom.
Something that makes me crazy is how the major tech companies are still the biggest holdings in most ESG (environmental and social governance) mutual funds and ETFs.
For example: $SUSL is a sustainable ETF people might choose if they don't want their retirement savings funding fossil fuels or warfare and whatnot, but NVIDIA, Microsoft, Google, and Tesla make up more than 40% of its holdings(!). They pass the "environmental" screen partly because they're not directly drilling oil or mining coal, and yet, in a way... aren't they?
(Also related, and apologies for the self-promotion, but you might enjoy this billionaire-bashing song I wrote, it's called Eat the Rich: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DdwlplpRd_Y/ )
There is so much here, both positive and negative, worthy of discussion and action. Marshall McLuhan told us years ago that "the medium is the message". We did not get it. Now the medium is the computer, AI and data centers, joined at the hip with energy generation. The message is that they matter more than people or the environment. As ecosystems collapse, sea levels rise, storms strengthen, and cities become incoherent, we need to recognize that energy consumption is the problem. Our demand accelerates faster than our ability to change supply. So we burn more oil, coal and gas to supply us with information that climate change is killing us. The system is the problem. Solar and wind are better but they cannot help within the operating system of the corporate oligopolies that control that system because they will always accelerate demand to maintain profitability above debt. Governance change can help, but if the selection of that governance depends on money generated by the system governed, will it willingly change the nature of governance? Right now we are seeing both governance and corporate malfeasance at its worst. Change is hard, but unless we willingly change to consume less in all sectors I don't see anything coming but a crash.
I don't think so. There always are questions about how polls are done, but I doubt a connection to the BBC. I have never seen, in years, any reporting where an environmental issue did any better in a question of priorities, including post voting polls. It seems impossible formany people who are ardent about such issues to understand how truly shallow public support is.
++++++More solar🌞 panels and battery-powered energy 🔋 for US!+++++
The big corporations are not the only one spinning backflips. Easily half of the renewable developers that I am connected to on LinkedIn are now working in data center development. The day to day work is virtually the same. The motivation is turned on its head. Fear (of not being able to get a job in renewables) and greed (the dollars are much, much bigger now) are the drivers.
Excellent compilation! Thank you!
Great piece (per usual). I have reservations, though, about continuing to use the word “greed” to explain these guys’ behavior. I think they’re now operating in a psycho-emotional realm far beyond greed. It’s more like an Olympian-level rutting extravaganza among a small group of situational narcissists in their quest for godlike status via the public crushing of male competitors. Essentially a giant game of “king of the mountain” whose real stakes - to which these warring gods are blind - is the suffering of the spectators.
I understand winning involves making the most money, and I understand greed can mean thirst for power as well as dollars, but I still think it’s an inadequate term for the impulse behind these men’s boundless level of ego-based, competitive amorality.
It woud be nice if companies would inrnalities the externalities that they cause, but its the job of policymakers to create the incentives for companies to do so (and the climate movement to create the incentives for politicians to do so)
Thank you Bill for your humor and the information.
The $10,000 checks aren't just corporate greed, they are the down payment on a massive state-backed bailout.
Bill, calling out Big Tech’s hypocrisy and community buyouts hits the mark on their PR rot, but treating this as merely "billionaire lying" misses the real game theory at play. Big AI Tech is staring down an astronomical CapEx bubble, billions sunk into GPUs and data center real estate with unviable unit returns. They aren't just bribing towns to build; they are executing a "Moral Hazard by Design" strategy.
By paying off local communities to force through zoning changes today, tech giants trick regional utilities and municipalities into incurring massive public debt to upgrade the grid. When the speculative AI bubble inevitably bursts, Big Tech won't take the hit, they'll default on or renegotiate their long-term Power Purchase Agreements under the guise of "market adjustments" or "climate-mandated pauses." Ratepayers and taxpayers will be left holding the bill for stranded fossil and grid infrastructure, socializing the losses while Big Tech walks away with privatized IP and state-sanctioned regulatory moats that lock out any remaining competition.
As one commenter Wayne Teel correctly noted above, energy consumption itself is the systemic engine, and as Brian’s poll data starkly shows, the general public ranks "climate" dead last when economic pressures hit. Swapping compute energy for a hyper-electrified "green" grid changes nothing. Wind, solar, and grid-scale batteries are rebuildable energy converters, industrial products reliant on destructive open-pit mining, toxic refining, and fossil fuels. You cannot engineer an inherently unsustainable, growth-dependent machine into sustainability. Industrial civilisation will not voluntarily shrink its throughput; it will run until nature’s limits force a catastrophic thermodynamic reset.
Are we heading for another '29?
Seren, comparing the current AI bubble to 1929 misses a fundamental difference in physical reality. The crash of 1929 was a paper financial panic occurring within a young, expanding industrial system that still had vast, unexploited reserves of high-EROEI oil, pristine topsoil, and massive ecological slack to rebuild upon. When that bubble burst, the physical resource base remained entirely intact, allowing credit and industrial capital to eventually re-expand and drive another multi-decade growth cycle.
A modern 2020s or 2030s crash will hit a society that is simultaneously suffering from energy limits, declining resource quality, and severe ecological overshoot. We are burning through finite, lower-grade fossil fuels just to build out "REbuildable" energy converters and data center grids that yield no real net-energy return. When this CapEx bubble bursts, it won't just wipe out paper wealth; it will paralyse physical supply chains and leave communities saddled with stranded grid liabilities at the exact moment nature's limits prevent us from ever rebuilding the high-energy machine. It won't be a temporary financial depression followed by a new boom, but a permanent step down the staircase of industrial decline.
Differences. Similarities.
Maybe. Maybe not.
Thank you
The gap between the pledge and the number is the part that gets me every time — emissions up double digits at multiple companies that made public net-zero commitments years ago. A pledge that isn't holding under its own growth targets isn't really a pledge anymore, it's a press release with an expiration date nobody announced.
Pledges mean nothing without accountability
I cannot wrap my head around the 'need' for expanding data centers to seemingly every corner of the world. What for? tRump and the META-verse team already live inside our heads and largely control our behaviors. And now perhaps the coup-de-grace, populous level bribery?
The plutocrats are swimming in dollars with nowhere to put them except projects that extirpate human individual sovereignty.
We’re talking about AI as if the transition to a cleaner energy system can happen underneath it automatically, while some of the fastest-growing AI infrastructure is creating new demand for gas and other fossil generation.
The question I keep asking is: what happens when AI demand grows faster than clean power and grid infrastructure can be built?
That timing gap may end up being one of the most important climate stories of the AI boom.
Something that makes me crazy is how the major tech companies are still the biggest holdings in most ESG (environmental and social governance) mutual funds and ETFs.
For example: $SUSL is a sustainable ETF people might choose if they don't want their retirement savings funding fossil fuels or warfare and whatnot, but NVIDIA, Microsoft, Google, and Tesla make up more than 40% of its holdings(!). They pass the "environmental" screen partly because they're not directly drilling oil or mining coal, and yet, in a way... aren't they?
(Also related, and apologies for the self-promotion, but you might enjoy this billionaire-bashing song I wrote, it's called Eat the Rich: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DdwlplpRd_Y/ )
Green Capitalism is no more possible than dry water. :
Capital tends to degrade the conditions of its own production.
Capital must expand without end in order to exist.
Capital leads to a chaotic world-system increasingly polarized between rich and poor,
which cannot adequately address the ecological crisis.
The combination makes an ever-growing ecological crisis an iron necessity so long as capital rules,
no matter what measures are taken to tidy up one corner or another.
—Joel Kovel
The climate and ecological crisis cannot be solved within today's political and economic systems.
That isn't an opinion. That's a fact.
—Greta Thunberg
That which does not confront the system becomes its instrument.
—Joel Kovel
There is so much here, both positive and negative, worthy of discussion and action. Marshall McLuhan told us years ago that "the medium is the message". We did not get it. Now the medium is the computer, AI and data centers, joined at the hip with energy generation. The message is that they matter more than people or the environment. As ecosystems collapse, sea levels rise, storms strengthen, and cities become incoherent, we need to recognize that energy consumption is the problem. Our demand accelerates faster than our ability to change supply. So we burn more oil, coal and gas to supply us with information that climate change is killing us. The system is the problem. Solar and wind are better but they cannot help within the operating system of the corporate oligopolies that control that system because they will always accelerate demand to maintain profitability above debt. Governance change can help, but if the selection of that governance depends on money generated by the system governed, will it willingly change the nature of governance? Right now we are seeing both governance and corporate malfeasance at its worst. Change is hard, but unless we willingly change to consume less in all sectors I don't see anything coming but a crash.
If climate pledges don't translate into measurable action, they're just marketing with better branding.
Wow. AI likes you, Bill...
This is just a comment on a local news item (for both of us). Here is a link to a very recent poll that Vermont Public did before the election. I just wanted to let you see the response to the second question, "What do you think is the most important problem facing the state of Vermont?" You will notice that the envionment/climate change response was dead last, at 1%, behind "other" and "don't know". Gives you great hope, I imagine, that our state is right in line with most of the country. https://www.vermontpublic.org/local-news/2026-09-28/vermont-general-election-poll-results-2026?utm_source=Vermont+Public&utm_campaign=02b03a9f19-breaking-poll-results-20260928&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_15bea94d3a-57518be892-588834589&mc_cid=02b03a9f19
Depressing. But not as depressing as the fact that 10% of respondents aren't sure whether Herr Trump is doing a good or bad job.
Actually that's a BBC poll. (Their news dept has been captured by the right wing.)
The question is weighted: "What do you think is the most important problem facing the state of Vermont?"
If everyone put "Environment/Climate change" as their second priority, it would score zero
I don't think so. There always are questions about how polls are done, but I doubt a connection to the BBC. I have never seen, in years, any reporting where an environmental issue did any better in a question of priorities, including post voting polls. It seems impossible formany people who are ardent about such issues to understand how truly shallow public support is.
Vermont Public has a BBC World Service logo. (Odd. I thought they only fund “shithole countries” lol.)
Yes agree re the shallow support but Bill is doing a great job on that.